Swades is a simple but serious story with a message to (NRI Non Resident Indians) NRI in this film is given a new meaning: not back Indian! It is the same as Oscar nomimated Gowariker of Lagaan, in scope and entertainment, but certainly has a similar theme, namely: the protagonist is in conflict with the social system there and try to win people’s support to change.
Even the structure of the story is similar. However, the treatment of this subject is much more serious and although there is some light hearted comic moments, most of the film is very serious and deals with contemporary problems depressing poverty, caste and illiteracy in parts of rural India and makes it sensitive, subtle and slow. No wonder Swades has not done well at the box office since it is subject.
Nor, I am surprised that neither has gone relatively unnoticed by Western critics, who seem to be typecast as anything that Bollywood is singing, dancing and coloring. Recently I was watching a special on Bollywood ‘DVD Review’ on BBC, where a critic of the West, expressed his criticism in the recent Bollywood film ‘Black’ who had reservations about calling Black a Bollywood film, their reasoning is simply Black because they conform to the framework of standard Bollywood. It really is like saying that the Moulin Rouge and Chicago are not Hollywood movies as it does not fit within the framework of Hollywood.
This ignorance can be applied to Western critics who call “Bride & Prejudice Bollywood movie. Knowing that this type of ‘critical’ Swades are reviewing is not surprising,
Swades that has gone unnoticed by them.
No “Bollywood” enough for his liking. Just by carrying out the above ignorant some of its mystery, the definition of a Bollywood film is a film that has been made by the film industry in Mumbai, India.
Now, moving to the rest of the review - Swades In my humble opinion is generally a product superior and more thought Lagaan causes in terms of history, depth, theme, music, direction and technical aspects. However, it lacks the universal crowd pleasing appeal of Lagaan and its epic qualities.
Swades also lacks the fluidity of people had Lagaan prey despite 4 hours runtime. That really can not be helped - given the issues Swades seeks to address.
I would have preferred that Gowariker has focused more on social issues that Mohan and his relationships. I have found to be disappointing and prolonged. Without giving spoilers, I will say that the final decision Mohan should have been different and the movie would have ended on a more ironic and powerful and be more relatable to an NRI.
This also would have finished with the last 20 minutes, which should have not gone the editing table. Swades is definitely worth seeing, as long as they will paitent with the film. If you are looking for entertainment, which also has Swades, but not much better films for this purpose.
However, if you want an intelligent and sensitive film about the real problems, and some melodious music and entertainment on the side, then it will not go wrong with Swades - 8 / 10